Hey, like my new, not-remotely-pretentious blog format, guys?
I sometimes laugh that I even have a blog. Almost every day's the same: I get up, go to work, do my boring job all day, trudge home, and spend the evening dwelling on all the things I'm too tired to actually do, but which might actually get out of my current situation if I had enough energy to do them. Sometimes I feel guilty about how little I like the situation I'm in since, after all, I have a job that adequately pays the rent, and a good boss.
I read this article today about the Millenial generation and felt perfectly pinned, except that the "lazy" Millenials she's describing in her office seem a lot less lazy and more motivated than I am. One thing that routinely bugs me, however, about critiques of the Millenial generation is how the writers of these articles so completely remove themselves from the situation. It's not as though the Millenial generation raised itself, or aliens dumped us here fully formed. Yes, each individual needs to take responsibility for who he or she becomes, but no one ever stops to ask if we could have been born into the era of yuppie greed, a booming growth of electronic entertainment, increased celebrity worship, "every child is special, can become president, can do what they want with their lives," and a decreased emphasis on having your kid pull his or her weight around the house, and be expected to turn out any differently.
My mom once described to me something called Maslow's Hierarchy, which describes the order in which people worry about their quality of life. Physiological needs come first (food, water, excretion, sex, etc), then safety (of self, family, resources), love/belonging, esteem (by self and others), then self-actualization. Once one level has been achieved, we worry about the next, but not until then (basically). Another criticism I've heard of the Millenial generation is that we move on from job to job too frequently -- always looking for a more fulfilling experience. Seen in context of Maslow's hierarchy, this only makes sense. A couple of generations ago, the primary need our culture emphasized was providing for the family. People dreamed of owning a house with the proverbial picket fence. After that was achieved and taken for granted, later generations worried more about financial security. Now we, who've been raised in perhaps the best economic climate in history, are all pursuing self-actualizing careers. Art teacher. Professor. Screen-writer. Novelist. Harsher critics might say we're actually pursuing more entertaining careers, and they may be right. How much can we really be blamed? Doesn't this seem like a natural progression, especially when many of us were raised with the attitude that settling for anything different in a job would be either materialistic or selling ourselves short?
What's scary is that the culmination of this trend is coinciding with the globalization of the job market and a population that's growing exponentially. So, yes, there's a good chance we'll have to settle for something less than exactly what we want to do with our careers. Maybe in 30 years we'll be worried about eating at all, but I hope not. Still, is it all that unreasonable to want to be happy? Even if our ideas about what would make us happy are a little inflated, or if we expect it to happen too readily? To not want to spend most of our waking lives being bored or miserable? Maybe this is our generation's burden to bear: being set up with unrealistic expectations, then having to face not only reality, but a grimmer reality than anyone saw coming. Yet, knowing all this, it's still hard to not want to shoot for a career that will make me happy.
On a lighter note ("Thank God," screams everyone), super-congratulations to the guy I mentioned earlier, Chris LaPorte, who just won ArtPrize! There's one self-actualized artist who won't have to worry about going hungry for a while.
"I have lived through much, and now I think I have found what is needed for happiness. A quiet secluded life in the country, with the possibility of being useful to people to whom it is easy to do good, and who are not accustomed to have it done to them; then work which one hopes may be of some use; then rest, nature, books, music, love for one's neighbor - such is my idea of happiness. And then, on top of all that, a mate, and children, perhaps - what more can the heart of man desire?"
- Tolstoy's "Family Happiness"
Ha, my mom went to the award ceremony and described the piece that won, and I was like, "Hey, Holly knows that guy!"
ReplyDeleteIt's interesting; I do use Carmen (our BlackBoard), e-mail, and YouTube for teaching, but I would never use Facebook or Twitter and get my work mixed up with my personal life like that.
I think the other thing that's changing is not just that we're pursuing self-actualizing careers, but that the career landscape has changed. Fifty years ago, men went to an office from 9-5 and came home, and now we have so many careers that we didn't have before, you can earn a living from blogging or selling things online, and the percentage of people who work a 9-5 is quite diminished. There was a quote in the movie The Social Network about how this generation doesn't want to get a job, they want to invent a job, and I think that's kind of cool.
And yet, at the end of the day, I shake my fists at those little punks who were born in the '90s and send 300 text messages a day, so...
Yeah, a lot of work-ppl I'm friends with on FB are fans of our company's page (and its various imprints), and I'm like... no. I like what my company does, just, no.
ReplyDeleteI've been wanting to see The Social Network -- I'll have to drag someone with me in the next few weeks. That is a very enterprising way of looking at us. I like it, even if, in my case at least, it's a bit flattering. I'm curious about the context.
Yeah, thems pesky kids and their incessant clicking and beeping. I'm pretty techno-reliant when it comes to that stuff, but I'm old school enough that at the same time I sort of wish it weren't true.
For me, I was raised with my dad, who is one of the smartest people I know, being sad his whole life that he didn't go past community college, got a job at the post office to pay the bills, and got stuck there. And he was always adamant that his kids not do that; that we pursue something that we love, that's going to fulfill us. Which is probably one of the reasons he's perfectly happy for me to live at home while I'm trying to do this writing thing. But I agree with all of what you wrote in general, too; the disparity of how most people in our generation were raised versus our parents' generation is huge - and if you look back at our grandparents, growing up during the Depression or WWII, it's even bigger.
ReplyDeleteNo, that makes a ton of sense -- I'm right there with you. I know people with similar stories -- parents always want something better for their kids, and I think dreams grow with each generation. My dad started out in sales jobs he didn't like, but now teaches stuff he finds very interesting at a local college, and he wanted that second stage for me, too. He was very big on pushing self-actualizing careers -- he always quoted Frost I think, saying "unite your vocation with your advocation." He especially liked talking about how much he liked going into a career where he could do some good. (He also, sort of by accident, glorified how easy he had it as a prof at a small school -- setting his own schedule, teaching interesting stuff, etc.)
ReplyDeleteBut at the same time, I get mixed messages from him. He's a huge worrier, wants to see me in something stable, worries about having spoiled me, and would *not* be a big supporter of me moving back in to try to get off my feet in a chosen career. Despite the fact that he's set me up with very strong ideas about what is and isn't a career to aim for. He loves the job I have now -- I'm close to home, I have a good boss, I'm contributing to an overall good cause -- and he wants me to stay here. But I'm miserable, I say. All I do is type someone else's emails all day, open mail, and answer phones. But I think he blocks this/has selective hearing. So yay for your dad keeping his messages straight, and backing you with that full support.
To be fair to him, I think he really just wants me to find something secure where I can be honest and do some good. It's not his fault I've got the art bug. (Actually, it sort of is, since the genes came from his side of the family.)
There are so many things that go into why our generation is the way it is -- I couldn't say everything I wanted to say without going on for twice as long, and I'm not going to begin to pretend I've got it all figured out. But that's part of what I was thinking -- we have the career goals we do at least partly if not mostly because of how we were raised. We were discouraged from settling. And I think that's a very good way to raise your kids -- much better than telling them to give up on the idea of being happy, or telling them to just go for more money. I just tend to freak out when I think too much about the odds of getting a job.
I really like this post, Holly. Even if you do the same thing day in and day out, you still have a great mind and I enjoy reading about what's going on in there :)
ReplyDeleteAnd "it's not as if the Millennial generation raised itself" ~ I'm gonna have to remember that.
::::thumbs up w/superbig hugs:::: :):):) Yay! Thanks! I'm really glad it you found it interesting and not just whiny/angsty/depressing. That's always the worry with posts like this. :)
ReplyDelete